What most people miss
"I got an unacceptable rating and the write-up is all positive." That gap matters more than people think. The rating is what systems and decision makers read first. The comments get read later, if at all. Translation: the number is the record.
Then comes the reply. A lot of people water it down because they still need their manager for other things. One person told me, "I didn't want to be too antagonistic because I needed them for other stuff." The record kept their version.
Clear and factual isn't difficult. It's the record. Say what the comments say, what you delivered and what you're asking them to correct.

